I have a 14 renegade with a warn winch on it that I shifted into neutral, now I can't seem to rotate the red handle to get it back into gear, I don't want to break it ,any suggestions?

Not really a Can Am specific topic, but I wanted to ask my Can Am brothers :) I'm Looking at installing a winch on my 2012 Rene 1000. I have it snorkelled and have 27 Outlaws, so I can manage to get it bogged fairly good. I'm looking at the Warn ProVantage 3500 with synthetic rope. Has anyone...